![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 1 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/1-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 1 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 2 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/2-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 2 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 3 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/3-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 3 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 4 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/4-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 4 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 5 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/5-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 5 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 6 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/6-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 6 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 7 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/7-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 7 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 8 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/8-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 8 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 9 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/9-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 9 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 10 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/10-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 10 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 11 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/11-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 11 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 12 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/12-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 12 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 13 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/13-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 13 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 14 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/14-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 14 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 15 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/15-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 15 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 16 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/16-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 16 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 17 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/17-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 17 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 18 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/18-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 18 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 19 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/19-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 19 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 20 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/20-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 20 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 21 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/21-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 21 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 22 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/22-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 22 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 23 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/23-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 23 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 24 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/24-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 24 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 25 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/25-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 25 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 26 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/26-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 26 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 27 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/27-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 27 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 28 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/28-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 28 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 29 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/29-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 29 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 30 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/30-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 30 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 31 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/31-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 31 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 32 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/32-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 32 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 33 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/33-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 33 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 34 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/34-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 34 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 35 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/35-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 35 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 36 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/36-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 36 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 37 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/37-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 37 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 38 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/38-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 38 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 39 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/39-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 39 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 40 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/40-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 40 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 41 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/41-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 41 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 42 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/42-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 42 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 43 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/43-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 43 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 44 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/44-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 44 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 45 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/45-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 45 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 46 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/46-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 46 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 47 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/47-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 47 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 48 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/48-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 48 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 49 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/49-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 49 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 50 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/50-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 50 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 51 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/51-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 51 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 52 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/52-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 52 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 53 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/53-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 53 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 54 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/54-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 54 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 55 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/55-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 55 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 56 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/56-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 56 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 57 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/57-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 57 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 58 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/58-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 58 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 59 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/59-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 59 - m.manganelo.com")
![Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 60 - m.manganelo.com](https://v16.mkklcdnv6tempv5.com/img/tab_16/00/23/26/xa953683/chapter_10_end_read_online/60-o.jpg "Shin Chimoguri Ringo to Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online page 60 - m.manganelo.com")
Shin Chimoguri Ringo To Kingyobachi Otoko Chapter 10 : [End] Read Online Summary
You're read Shin Chimoguri Ringo To Kingyobachi Otoko manga online at m.manganelo.com. Alternative(s) : New Blood Diver Ringo and the Fishbowl Man ; New Chimoguri Ringo and the Goldfish Bowl Man - Author(s) : Abe Youichi
Facebook Comments